Thursday, December 17, 2009

Benoit Alain Ducasse: Does NYC Need Another French Bistro?

Benoit,Alain Ducasse,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photograhy
Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Bread Pouch,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Onion Soup,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Goat Cheese Salad,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Cassoulet,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Braised Halibut,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
Sirloin Steak,Benoit,New York,French Bistro,Passport Foodie,Taylor Young Photography
I wasn't doing a blog in the 80's, nor was I interested in food. Well, besides Fruit Roll Ups and Ring Pops. Remember those? So I wasn't around to see the great French Bistro explosion that took New York City by storm. Bistros such as The Odeon apparently sprung up every week during this boom time. It quickly faded away as fast as it came, but now it seems that there are more and more French style Bistros opening up in the city. Don't get me wrong, I love it. The Bistro is my favorite kind of restaurant and they serve my favorite kind of food. The fact that New Yorkers are embracing this trend again makes tears come to my eyes and butterflies flutter in my stomach. Among all the new Bistros is Alain Ducasse's, Benoit.

The place was almost completely empty when we walked in, but 6:30pm is fairly early to eat dinner in New York. I hate it when I go into a restaurant that has more staff then they know what to do with. It always feels like I'm being swarmed by Killer Bees. Dozens of people hovered over us inspecting our every move. Each time I took my camera out at least 4 employees were looking at me like I was a stain on their untarnished restaurant. The decor is lovely in Benoit, it felt exactly like I was in a proper French Bistro on the Champs Elysees, or Montmartre.

Needless to say, we were waited on very quickly. The waiter took our drink orders, then another man brought us bread in a fabulous Benoit cloth pouch. A nice touch. Not as nice as Bouchon, where the bread is thrown straight onto the tablecloth, but close. Our wine, a Twenty Rows Cabernet, in a lovely carafe came out first. It was followed swiftly by my Onion Soup Gratinee, which was among the best Onion Soups I've ever had. The cheese was melted and browned to perfection. The Onions were ripe and delicious. It was also possibly the hottest thing I've ever put into my mouth and I still have the Ulcers on my tongue to prove it. My wife had the Goat Cheese Salad with Candy Beets, Tomato and Avocado. This was a strikingly simple, but wonderfully flavored dish. The Beets were tender, but crispy at the same time and the tastes were married nicely.

For my main I had Cassoulet, which is Jean-Jacques Rachou’s recipe. I had actually never had Cassoulet before and this was a wonderful first taste. It is likely the most filling dish I know. While eating it, I was transported to a small French farmhouse. I could imagine myself sitting at a rustic table, eating my Cassoulet, while La Vie En Rose played on an antique Phonograph, the sound muffled and scratchy. Anyway, back to reality. After my Cassoulet was finished and my belly felt like it was about to explode and ruin the waiters mood completely, I decided a little break was in order. But not before trying my wife's Braised Halibut with Sautéed Chanterelle Mushrooms, Root Vegetables and Champagne Sabayon. Now, I have had a lot of Fish from Bistros before and I always marvel at the richness, the complexity and the depth of the Bistro style Fish. But not this time. No, this was bland and boring. There's no other way to describe it. I decided to move onto Simple Foodie's Sirloin Steak Aux Poivres with Mixed Vegetables. Normally Simple Foodie orders the best thing on the menu, he always has, but not this time. The Steak was cooked very well and it was among the most tender Steaks I've ever tasted, but it was also one of the most...hmmm, how do I say this without repeating myself? There's no way to do it, BORING.

That was pretty much the theme of Benoit. I truly enjoyed the atmosphere, especially the couple sitting to our right. They were like something out of a Woody Allen movie. Clearly they ate at Benoit on a regular basis as they knew everyone by name and they actually had the Chef prepare meals that were off the menu. I didn't speak to my fellow diners almost the entire meal because I was too enthralled in their conversation. They were stereotypical New Yorkers from a bygone era. They were loud, they ate with their mouths open like they were at a cattle trough and they complained about absolutely everything. It was a life changing experience.

Our waiter asked us if we wanted any Dessert and I had to refuse. The Cassoulet did me in. I can't say that I would ever go back to Benoit again. The food was so, so and later that evening I woke up with food poisoning. I have no idea what caused it. An email to the restaurant was answered with a refund and the excuse that no one else informed them of any illness from the food that night. Oh well, thankfully there are many more Bistros in New York to explore.

My professional photography website: Taylor Young Photography

Benoit on Urbanspoon


  1. Though the main courses may have been boring (poor you), the photos are not. In fact, the photos make the food look...well...mouth-watering. That Onion Gratinee (which was NOT boring) looks fabulous!

  2. Main Street One,

    Thank you very much!

    Yes, the Onion Soup was absolutely divine!


  3. Ring Pops are still popular Taylor :P

    Sorry to hear about the food poisoning! A great first experience of cassoulet overshadowed by an illness. Hope you're feeling better.

    Happy holidays and happy new year!!

  4. Sean,

    Are you serious?

    This is the best news I've heard in years. I love Ring Pops. :)

    Happy Holidays, my friend.


  5. Wow it looks delicious, and the photos are beautiful.

  6. My husband & I both got food poisoning upon eating at Benoit on 12/28/10. He didn't even make it out of the restaurant and then vomited in the cab. I at least made it back to the hotel and then was up all night.

    1. Amazing!

      Clearly Benoit needs to sort out where they source their food!

      Thanks for the comment!